At a glance
How to read- Identity
- Confirmed
- Level
- Ad 1.10m
- Price
- $100,000 · fair $71,250–$84,960 · negotiate first
What to do next
Talk to your trainer before you negotiate
High vs market vs similar horses. Your trainer can tell you if the horse is worth pursuing anyway.
- Send this report to your trainer and ask whether it is worth a call or trial.
- If your trainer is interested, ask for a recent show video at your target level.
- Use the fair-price range in this report as context — not a guarantee — if you negotiate.
Comturo HPF II — Horse Scouts buyer research USEF #5643607 · COMME IL FAUT x W-GOYA P&B · 7yo Level: ad 1.10m Price: Sale: $100,000 · High vs market Identity: High confidence Report: https://horsescouts.pro/r/comturo-hpf-ii?detail=full
Is the price fair?
High vs marketSale: $100,000 · fair $71,250–$84,960
Currently for sale
$71,250–$96,250
Asking prices of 6 comparable listings (context, not value)
Estimated value
$68,400–$92,400
Adjusted for this horse's record (-4% vs. band)
| Performance vs. level & win rate | -10% | USEF record found but height not parsed — conservative adjustment; Weak placing trend on USEF record |
|---|---|---|
| Age / runway | +6% | Developing (6–9) — long competitive runway + resale optionality |
Estimated value weights the horse's show record, rideability, age, and typical ask-to-sale gap. Decision aid, not a certified appraisal.
Asking price
$100,000
Based on comparable listing asks and show record — not sold prices or a certified appraisal.
The asking price looks high compared to similar horses for sale. That is about $28,000 above the middle of our fair range.
The asking price usually does not include: PPE / vetting, shipping, sales commission (if you use an agent).
Similar listings in this band
- Eisi US — $100,000 · 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m
- Colman WH — $85,000 · 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m
- Tokio Van Schuttershof Z — $75,000 · 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m
USEF record found but height not parsed — conservative adjustment
Market context
Priced from: BIGEQ (9)
- 6 similar listings in our sample.
- Asking prices run $70,000–$100,000.
- Our fair-range midpoint for this horse is $72,000.
Before you call the seller
Three questions to start — open Full research for contact info and the full checklist.
- Book a pre-purchase exam (PPE) with a vet you choose before you buy.
- Ask about past injuries, surgeries, or ongoing maintenance the vet should know about.
- Why is the horse for sale, and can you ride or trial the horse in person before you commit?
Does the ad check out?
1 flagOne item in the ad needs confirming. Ask the seller about the flagged row before you go further.
| What the ad says | Public records | Our read |
|---|---|---|
| USEF #5643607 | Same horse in USEF | Checks out |
| Sire: COMME IL FAUT | COMME IL FAUT | Checks out |
| Dam: W-GOYA P&B | W-GOYA P&B | Checks out |
| Jumps 1.10m | No show record at this height | Ask for video |
| Asking Sale: $100,000 | Similar horses $71,250–$84,960 | High vs market |
Is this the right horse?
Pedigree confirmedHorseTelex profile on file matches this horse · chip …888820. Confirm microchip and papers match the horse you inspect.
- Born
- 1 Jan 2019
- Age
- 7 years old · USEF foal date
- Breed
- Holsteiner
- Color
- BAY
- Sex
- Gelding
- Sire
- COMME IL FAUT
- Dam
- W-GOYA P&B
- Dam's sire
- CANTURO
- U.S. registry #
- 5643607
- Microchip
- 981020021888820
International record (FEI)
cross ref sire COMME IL FAUT · dam W-GOYA P&B · up to 1.10m claimed · verify on data.fei.org
Video
How long can you ride this horse?
This horse is 7 years old. If sound, you might get about 6–10 more years of useful jumping at this level.
Based on age band (Developing (6–9)). Useful-years estimates follow FEI show-jumping age profiles: peak performance commonly occurs around ages 10–15, with many Grand Prix horses active into the mid-teens and beyond when sound. At 7, the horse is still in a developing window — PPE findings should be weighed against upside to the stated level. [5][6]
Vet & pre-purchase exam
Sport-horse literature treats a pre-purchase exam (PPE) as a risk assessment — not pass/fail. Radiographic findings are common in sound jumpers and must be read in context of age, intended use, current performance, and price [1][2].
Before you buy, book an independent sport-horse vet you choose. Share this report so the exam can target gaps between seller claims and public records.
- Baseline PPE: soundness exam, flexions, and imaging scoped to price point and intended use [4].
- At this age, expect minimal degenerative change on imaging — clean hocks, minimal fetlock or navicular remodeling.
- Findings that warrant extra scrutiny: significant osteoarthritis, advanced remodeling, or chronic soft-tissue injury.
- Literature supports interpreting mild isolated radiographic changes cautiously when the horse is currently sound and performing.
- Ask for injury history, surgeries, joint maintenance, and any prior vet records the seller can share.
About 57% of prepurchase exams document at least one potentially prejudicial finding — presence alone does not predict future unsoundness [2]. Mild gait asymmetry is also common and may not correlate with clinical lameness [3].
Sources for vet & age guidance
- van Hoogmoed & Snyder (1999). van Hoogmoed LM, Snyder JR. Prepurchase Examination of Jumpers and Dressage Horses. AAEP Proceedings, 1999.
- Equine Veterinary Journal (2024). Equine Veterinary Journal. "Prejudicial Findings During Prepurchase Examinations," 2024.
- University of Utrecht (2022). University of Utrecht. Movement Asymmetries in Horses Presented for PPE and Lameness Evaluation, 2022.
- Merck Veterinary Manual. Merck Veterinary Manual. Prepurchase Examination of Horses.
- FEI Facts and Figures (2020). FEI Annual Report 2020 — average registered horse age 9.85 years; Jumping athlete demographics and age distribution.
- FEI / Bristol University longevity research. FEI Sports Forum (2026) — ongoing FEI–Bristol research on career longevity, competition intensity, and retirement factors in Jumping horses.
Horse Scouts summarizes published sport-horse veterinary literature for informational purposes only. It is not veterinary, legal, or financial advice and creates no legally binding obligation. Consult your own veterinarian before any purchase decision. See our Terms of Service.
Show record
Prize money
USEF prize money on file
Last competition
42 - Performance Hunter 3’3 NEHC/MHC “AA” · Placed 7
Usage rate
67 starts, active 3 of the last 12 months
Goes for
Some amateur/junior mileage; rest in open divisions
Eliminations / retirements
Completed all 67 starts on record
German national record (equi-score)
skipped No equi-score URL and no European show footprint to search on.
German and Austrian national shows (Kl. E/A/L/M/S) often do not appear on FEI or USEF. Paste an equi-score class result URL when you submit research to target a specific show.
- 3% win rate — below average compared to similar listed jumpers at 1.10-1.19m (median ~9%, based on 11 horses with records).
U.S. record (USEF)
confirmed 67 USEF class starts · 2 wins (3% win rate) · sire COMME IL FAUT (no YOB on dossier — set identity.yob for full career range)
Last competed: May 17, 2026
| Date | Class | Placing | Rider |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 17, 2026 | 42 - Performance Hunter 3’3 NEHC/MHC “AA” | 7 | CHELSEA FRANCIS |
| May 17, 2026 | 43 - Performance Hunter 3’3 NEHC/MHC “AA” | 5 | CHELSEA FRANCIS |
| May 17, 2026 | 11116 - Green Hunter 3’3/3'6 NEHC/MHC “AA" (COMBINED) - FP | 2 | CHELSEA FRANCIS |
| May 17, 2026 | 11117 - Green Hunter 3’3/3'6 NEHC/MHC “AA" (COMBINED) | 3 | CHELSEA FRANCIS |
| May 17, 2026 | 11120 - Green Hunter 3’3/3'6 NEHC/MHC “AA" U/S (COMBINED) | 3 | CHELSEA FRANCIS |
| May 17, 2026 | 217 - Equitation 36 & Over NEHC/MHC “AA” Flat | 4 | JENNIFER NADEAU |
Ask the seller
Contact
- Location
- Rehoboth, MA
Full question checklist
This report summarizes public records only. Always verify answers with the seller, your trainer, and your vet before you buy.
What the seller says Pasted ad text · tap to expand
“Dan” is a 2019 17.3 Holsteiner, bred for the Grand Prix ring, but is instead proving an ideal fit for the big eq and international derbies. Brought along slowly and correctly, Dan stepped into the 3’6 performance hunter ring this year with ease, bringing home multiple tri colors at top venues. Uncomplicated, brave, careful, and always willing to take a joke, Dan shines in any ring he enters. An ideal partner for a junior or amateur looking for a competitive, reliable horse to continue developing through the ranks. Dan is a delight to have in the barn — an endearing, big goofy gelding personality. He is easy to travel with and behaves very well for vet, farrier, clipping, etc. Located in Rehoboth, MA Also Available for trial iweek 6 hits Saugerties and Fairfield/CHJA finals Low 6 to keep Mid/high 5 to borrow
Advertised around 1.1m — not fully verified in public records yet.
Seller statements are unverified until USEF, video, and your own inspection back them up.
Similar horses for sale 6 listings
| Horse | Age | Price | Level | Days listed | Win rate | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eisi US | 6 | $100,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 24 days | 5% | View |
| Colman WH | 7 | $85,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 53 days | 2% | View |
| Tokio Van Schuttershof Z | 6 | $75,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 21 days | 2% | View |
| Better Man | 10 | $100,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 32 days | 7% | View |
| your horse here. | 8 | $70,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 52 days | — | View |
| Calvin | 9 | $70,000 | 3'6" or 1.05, 1.10m | 13 days | 9% | View |
Find prior listings abroad Search for prior European listings
No European source price on file yet. Use the links below to find the origin listing — then we can compute the dealer spread.
Search for prior listings abroad
European producers often post sale ads on public Facebook Pages that Google indexes. These two searches are usually enough to find the origin price.
What we could not verify1 gap
Use these if your trainer wants detail — not a reason to panic on their own.
- No confirmed ClipMyHorse horse profile — use the search link for possible videos and verify identity.
Sources & import costs
Where we looked
| Source | Status | Notes | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| U.S. show registry (USEF) | confirmed | 67 USEF class starts · 2 wins (3% win rate) · sire COMME IL FAUT (no YOB on dossier — set identity.yob for full career range) | Open |
| International registry (FEI) | cross_ref | sire COMME IL FAUT · dam W-GOYA P&B · up to 1.10m claimed · verify on data.fei.org | Open |
| Pedigree (HorseTelex) | needs_review | sire COMME IL FAUT · dam GOYA P&B · dam sire CANTURO | Open |
| German national results (equi-score) | skipped | No equi-score URL and no European show footprint to search on. | — |
| Show video (ClipMyHorse) | no_match | No confirmed ClipMyHorse horse profile for "Comturo HPF II" — open search by name; videos may appear (verify it's the same horse). | Open |
Import costs & logistics
U.S. show jumping relies heavily on imported European warmbloods (KWPN, BWP, Holsteiner, Oldenburg, Selle Français, and others). The listing price is often only part of the investment — veterinary, transport, quarantine, customs, and insurance can add roughly 10–30% or more to landed cost [3].
Estimate for this horse
This listing appears to be in the U.S. — no international import is required for domestic delivery. If you source from Europe instead, use the categories and illustrative totals below as a planning guide.
Typical cost categories
| Category | Typical range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-purchase exam (PPE) | $1,000–$3,500+ | Independent vet exam before purchase — not part of shipping but essential risk management. |
| Export testing & documentation | $500–$3,000 | Health certificates, blood tests, and government export paperwork (varies by origin country). |
| International air transport | $10,000–$25,000+ | Largest logistics cost — shared vs. private stall, route, and season affect pricing. |
| Quarantine & federal inspection | $1,000–$5,000+ | USDA port inspection and quarantine length depend on origin disease status (often 3–7 days for EU geldings). |
| Customs & import brokerage | $500–$2,000 | Specialized equine brokers coordinate USDA, customs entry, and airport logistics. |
| Ground transportation | $500–$3,000+ | Seller to export airport, then U.S. arrival port to your barn. |
| Mortality / transit insurance | 1–4% of value / yr | Many buyers insure during transport; annual mortality often scales with horse value. |
Illustrative landed totals
Planning bands — actual costs vary by origin, sex (CEM rules for mares/stallions), route, and broker.
| Purchase price | Typical import stack | Est. landed cost |
|---|---|---|
| $50,000 | $12,000–$20,000 | $62,000–$70,000 |
| $100,000 | $12,000–$25,000 | $112,000–$125,000 |
| $250,000 | $15,000–$35,000 | $265,000–$285,000 |
Evaluate landed cost, not purchase price alone, when comparing to U.S. comps or judging resale potential. Ask the seller for export readiness, quarantine port, and who coordinates USDA paperwork.
Sources for import & logistics
- USDA APHIS. USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service. Importing live equines — permits, port inspection, and quarantine requirements.
- US Equestrian. USEF. International travel for horses — health documents, quarantine ports, and planning timelines.
- Aguilera (2020). Aguilera M. Global Horse Trade in the United States: 1981–2013. Society and Animals — documents the shift to European sport-horse imports in U.S. jumping.
- Kingston Stables. Kingston Stables. EU→U.S. all-in shipping guide (flight, papers, USDA quarantine) — industry planning benchmark.
Comparable metrics
Market sample: 6 similar listings · median $80,000 · interquartile $71,250–$96,250.
Comparable listings by marketplace: BIGEQ (9) · catalog 2026-07-20.
Win rate 3% (subject) vs 9% median among comps with records.
Comparable listings average $83,333 vs asking $100,000.
Show record vs similar listings
3% win rate — below average compared to similar listed jumpers at 1.10-1.19m (median ~9%, based on 11 horses with records).
Cohort win rate: min 2% · median 9% · max 38% (11 comps with USEF/SJW records).
Report date: 2026-07-21. Pricing uses BIGEQ (9) listings (catalog: BIGEQ · 2026-07-20 · HJx · 2026-07-20 · ProEquest · 2026-07-20).
Automated buyer research from public records — not a pre-purchase exam, veterinary opinion, or guarantee of seller claims. Verify identity, price, and soundness with your team before you buy.